Though I made the decision not to intervene in the situation I reported, and I told mother of my decision, she wrote me this wonderful e-mail. I hope that I deserve her kind words, and that I do make a difference for people - even when I do not personally represent them. I believe in what my colleagues and I do in defending people. It is not just the way I make a living, but it is the way I try to live my life. Helping. Here is a portion of her e-mail:
"Thank you for your kindness in answering me. Though not the answer I prayed for, I appreciate your attention and perspective . . . I was hoping so much from your initial response (I realize now the misunderstanding) that there was a break in the exhaustion and frustration in trying to defend [son] . . .
So I will soldier on in my fight for his representation, but a bit wiser from your words and my belief in humanity lifted being reminded that there are still people who care about right or wrong even when it doesn't pertain exclusively to them. I so respect the warrior in you and your keeping your eye and having the courage to call BS when you have come to the conclusion something must be done. I wish a lawyer not doing anything at all equalled a lawyer doing something wrong.
. . . Should I be successful [in getting another lawyer appointed], I would ask for you to be appointed. . . . Should I win the lottery or break down and take a loan against my home, I will contact you.
Whatever this challenge brings, I want you to know that people like you are rare and that you do make a positive difference. Thank you for championing me when you thought it right and for having honor. . . ." [signed mother]
This note made my year.
Criminal defense lawyer based in Houston, Harris County, Texas, posting hopefully to help others, & to entertain (even if it is just myself.)
Showing posts with label defense lawyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defense lawyer. Show all posts
Wednesday, October 13, 2010
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
I Don't Get Involved
So an update. After several e-mails back and forth between me and concerned mother, I was finally able to get a quote from the recording. It was, in essence, that if mother had the ability to pay for a in-patient drug rehab facility, the lawyer thought that the judge might consider it. The implication was that in the lawyer's opinion, the court would not waste county resources on the kid to give him another shot, and that the court would not consider the free program being proposed by mother.
THIS is a completely different situation than the one I think was first presented to me. I'm glad that I hesitated and got the quote. While one might disagree with the manner in which the lawyer is proceeding (many details left out), one cannot find that lawyer is being unethical with mother or kid. Lawyer is just trying to figure out how to get around the judge's general rules to help kid.
It truly is a matter of misunderstanding, and the situation will continue to be misunderstood, I'm afraid. Mother, while a loving and caring person, is likely an enabler because she has every excuse in the world for kid and his problems. (He committed at least one burglary of a habitation while out for the day from his rehab program. One of those situations that make it hard to justify giving him another chance at rehab.)
So, I guess I got involved enough to determine that this is not an unusual situation, and that the lawyer has probably not done anything wrong. My "super hero" cape shall go back into the closet and I will, once again, mind my own business.
THIS is a completely different situation than the one I think was first presented to me. I'm glad that I hesitated and got the quote. While one might disagree with the manner in which the lawyer is proceeding (many details left out), one cannot find that lawyer is being unethical with mother or kid. Lawyer is just trying to figure out how to get around the judge's general rules to help kid.
It truly is a matter of misunderstanding, and the situation will continue to be misunderstood, I'm afraid. Mother, while a loving and caring person, is likely an enabler because she has every excuse in the world for kid and his problems. (He committed at least one burglary of a habitation while out for the day from his rehab program. One of those situations that make it hard to justify giving him another chance at rehab.)
So, I guess I got involved enough to determine that this is not an unusual situation, and that the lawyer has probably not done anything wrong. My "super hero" cape shall go back into the closet and I will, once again, mind my own business.
Thursday, October 8, 2009
Prosecutorial Mindset - "My" Witnesses
Jim Leitner, currently one of the head honchos of the Harris County District Attorney's office, attended the DIVO presentation yesterday just long enough to be on a panel. He did not listen to the presentation, and to my knowledge, has not attended a presentation to learn about the program. But, he had been told about it at least somewhat and was there to represent the view of the DA's office.
As he related, the DA's office is completely against the idea. I cannot quote verbatim what he said about the program but generally it was that the defense would abuse the situation in some way.
First the rules - a defense lawyer must make at least an effort to talk to all witnesses in a case. The definition of witness can vary, and does not necessarily mean "eye witness", especially in a capital case.
Witnesses are just that - people who know something about the offense, the complainant (victim), the defendant, etc. They belong to no one, and in fact, if my memory serves correctly, it is unethical for one side (defense or prosecution) to advise a witness not to talk to the other side. (They can tell them that they do not have to talk to the other side but they cannot tell them they cannot.) Indeed, what fairness is it if you can't determine what the witnesses are going to say so that you can (1) make a decision how to proceed - you might advise the client to plead guilty, (2) prepare for trial, etc.
So, when Jim Leitner was talking about the position of the DA's office, the most interesting thing he said was to refer to the survivors of the victims of capital murder as "my witnesses." MY witnesses. (Of course, I had to correct him & remind him that they are "the" witnesses & do not belong to either side.)
What makes this assertion of particular interest is that Jim used to be a defense lawyer, and he was widely known for his work on capital cases.
If the leadership in the DA's office opening takes such a position of "ownership" of witnesses knowingly in my presence as well as distinguished defense lawyer Kathryn Kase (there were probably about 20 people in the room including the presenters), what can we expect they are teaching their underlings? What can the defense expect is being related to those against whom we try cases? Was it just a mistake? Or, as I believe is more likely given my experiences in trial of late, was the mistake only that he said publicly what he believes and how the trial prosecutors are being taught?
[Read my last post about what DIVO is for additional information.]
As he related, the DA's office is completely against the idea. I cannot quote verbatim what he said about the program but generally it was that the defense would abuse the situation in some way.
First the rules - a defense lawyer must make at least an effort to talk to all witnesses in a case. The definition of witness can vary, and does not necessarily mean "eye witness", especially in a capital case.
Witnesses are just that - people who know something about the offense, the complainant (victim), the defendant, etc. They belong to no one, and in fact, if my memory serves correctly, it is unethical for one side (defense or prosecution) to advise a witness not to talk to the other side. (They can tell them that they do not have to talk to the other side but they cannot tell them they cannot.) Indeed, what fairness is it if you can't determine what the witnesses are going to say so that you can (1) make a decision how to proceed - you might advise the client to plead guilty, (2) prepare for trial, etc.
So, when Jim Leitner was talking about the position of the DA's office, the most interesting thing he said was to refer to the survivors of the victims of capital murder as "my witnesses." MY witnesses. (Of course, I had to correct him & remind him that they are "the" witnesses & do not belong to either side.)
What makes this assertion of particular interest is that Jim used to be a defense lawyer, and he was widely known for his work on capital cases.
If the leadership in the DA's office opening takes such a position of "ownership" of witnesses knowingly in my presence as well as distinguished defense lawyer Kathryn Kase (there were probably about 20 people in the room including the presenters), what can we expect they are teaching their underlings? What can the defense expect is being related to those against whom we try cases? Was it just a mistake? Or, as I believe is more likely given my experiences in trial of late, was the mistake only that he said publicly what he believes and how the trial prosecutors are being taught?
[Read my last post about what DIVO is for additional information.]
Labels:
"my witnesses",
defense lawyer,
Jim Leitner,
prosecution
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)